It’s been nearly two months since Kyle Cooke and Amanda Batula announced their split, but the drama just won’t quit. 

Kyle recently appeared on Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen (March 10) to address rumors that he cheated on Amanda before their January 2026 separation. 

"It’s tough, there’s so much noise," he told host Andy. "I feel bad she’s had to deal with that. I can tell you I was not physically or emotionally unfaithful."

But Bravoholics aren’t buying it. 

When guest star Danny Pellegrino confronted Kyle about photos circulating online of him getting too close to fans, Kyle quickly fired back.

"The pictures I’ve seen are with people who are my friends that are mistaken for random people," the Loverboy founder explained. 

Fans of Summer House have long followed the couple’s ups and downs and many say there are simply too many photos, stories, and sources documenting Kyle’s untrustworthy behavior over the years.

 "At this point, he’s like the boy who cried wolf," one fan commented on social media. "You can’t just sweep all of that under the rug."

Kyle himself admitted to past mistakes, including a cheating incident back in 2018 when he and Amanda first started dating. He actually praised Amanda for tackling the incident head on and with confidence. 

"It takes effort," he said. "I mean, I couldn’t open my phone for two months, I was drowning in it. But she’s been very supportive. I try to be there for her, especially with some of the rumors she’s entangled with. It’s not easy, there’s not playbook on how to navigate this, but we’re trying."

Many are rooting for Amanda to move on and find a partner who’s genuinely trustworthy. 

"Amanda deserves love and happiness,” another viewer shared. “Someone who’s actually in it for the long haul."

Some are also predicting that Kyle may struggle to find love again.

@forthefanspod None of this should be surprising. Get the full lowdown on For The Fans podcast, everywhere you get your podcasts. #SummerHouse #KyleCooke #Bravo #PopCulture #popculturepodcast ♬ original sound - For The Fans Podcast

"He’s a walking red flag with baggage at this point," one Bravoholic wrote. In fact, the founders of Fandom Daily have their own Kyle encounter story, spotting him out in NYC getting unusually close with fans and noticeably, without his wedding ring.

While Kyle continues to deny any wrongdoing and remains single, the Summer House fandom is watching closely. Between the past drama, the ongoing rumors, and his public persona, many agree that regaining trust will not be easy. Meanwhile, all eyes remain on Amanda, with fans cheering her on as she navigates life post-split. 

You can catch the next episode of Summer House Tuesdays at 8 p.m. on Bravo.